deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

What do you think about selling prints of fan art? (Naruto, Sonic, Xmen, Star Trek, etc) 

37%
10 deviants said It is only acceptable when you're selling prints of your own original characters.
22%
6 deviants said Screw copyrights! We should be able to sell prints of any art we create!
19%
5 deviants said It depends on the fan art.
15%
4 deviants said It depends... (explain)
7%
2 deviants said It is never acceptable!

Devious Comments

:iconbaeowulf:
Only if it has an element that belongs to you.
Reply
:iconmikaelgrizzly:
Depends on the content. Any original creation of the artist is not subject to the original material copyright, if the work does not include trademarked/copyrighted material.

However, attempting to profit from a fan art containing copyrighted material counts as a violation and you're subject to prosecution.

It's kind of a gray zone in law, to be honest.
Reply
:iconsonichomeboy:
*SonicHomeboy Aug 16, 2007  Hobbyist General Artist
I'd do the fan art, but I'd never go as far in selling them as prints.
Reply
:iconcybernetichero:
I asked a friend who knows copyright about a similar subject when I painted my dalek picture and his answer is that all fan art is a technical breach of copyright but that the owners generally turn a blind eye because fan art only makes their franchise more popular and suing would be public relations suicide, not to mention never ending.
This is not always the case and some copyright owners are very touchy about how their characters are portrayed.
I think however that the definition of fan art stops short of prints made for the express purpose of selling and you are at the point at which your people should do lunch with their people.

omg, I sound like such a net nerd rofl
Reply
:iconlavanah:
Copyrights are serious. You can get into big trouble by selling something that isn't yours.
Reply
:iconulario:
=Ulario Aug 16, 2007  Professional Digital Artist
I realize that. I know that scouts for Disney frequently attend bazaars and confenscate and works that have mickey mouse/winnie the pooh/etc on them.

However, I personally see no problem with it if the picture in question is an original character that the artist (or someone else) has created. For example, I have done commissions of other people's original MMORPG characters... and of course, those are based off of WoW. Star Wars, etc. Since they are something that the person who commissioned it created, I saw no problems with it. But I would never accept a commission of a copyrighted character, such as Luke Skywalker or the like.
Reply
:iconlavanah:
Fan-based character commissions havedbeen making me think lately. Yes, the character does belong to its creator, but that character would never have been created if the comissioner hadn't see the show/book in the first place. It's the "idea" thing that's getting at me. It's hard for me to explain.
Reply
:iconguilrel:
I'm not sure I think it depends on the people who are you letting you sell this stuff. :hmm: Or if the company who made the characters care about that. I'm not sure. :confused:
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History